Software Error Added 6,600 Noncitizens to NJ Rolls

Voting sign on door leading to polling place
Photo: Gino Santa Maria / Shutterstock

New Jersey admitted that a software failure put about 6,600 noncitizens onto voter rolls and that fewer than 400 ballots were cast by people caught in that net, and now the Republican National Committee (RNC) is threatening legal action to force full records and fixes.

Story Snapshot

  • Governor Mikie Sherrill said a Motor Vehicles Commission error registered about 6,600 noncitizens.
  • State officials said fewer than 400 ballots were cast by people later flagged as ineligible.
  • The RNC served National Voter Registration Act notices and demanded records statewide.
  • New Jersey says it has removed about 5,100 and is reviewing more than 1,400 registrations.

What New Jersey Admitted And What Changed On The Rolls

Governor Mikie Sherrill said on July 21 that a Motor Vehicles Commission software failure between June 2023 and June 2024 registered about 6,600 people who had said they were not citizens. Sherrill said fewer than 400 of those later cast ballots in different elections, and that the state began removals while counties reviewed edge cases. By mid‑August, the state said about 5,100 were in deleted status and about 1,450 were in rejected status pending checks, with more reviews ongoing.

State officials stressed the error came from the system, not from applicants trying to vote when they knew they could not. Reports say some flagged people may be citizens after all, which is why several thousand records went to county review first. That mix matters for public trust. Bad data on the rolls erodes confidence. Wrongly removing a citizen does the same. Both sides of that risk sit inside this one failure window.

Why The RNC Is Threatening To Sue

The Republican National Committee sent formal violation notices under the National Voter Registration Act to the New Jersey secretary of state and several counties. The notices seek records on citizenship checks, removals, and voter‑roll maintenance since 2023. The RNC pointed to Bergen County records that show 134 noncitizens removed since January 2023, with most linked to Motor Vehicles Commission transactions, to argue the problem was not isolated to one list or month. The group says records will show more fixes are needed.

House Republican leaders also pressed New Jersey for answers and documents. They cited the state’s public admission of the 6,600 erroneous registrations and asked for communications and technical files that explain how the failure happened and how it will be prevented going forward. Their move mirrors the RNC push. Both efforts center on one core question that voters of all stripes ask: who is watching the watchers, and where is the paper trail when systems fail?

How Big The Voting Impact Was — And What We Still Do Not Know

Public statements so far point to fewer than 400 ballots cast by people later flagged from the error pool, with no official breakdown by county or contest released yet. That fact draws two lines. One, rolls were clearly contaminated, which undercuts trust. Two, the number of improper votes that officials have described so far is measured in the hundreds, not thousands, which undercuts the loudest claims of widespread illegal voting. Without case‑level files, the exact count and context remain limited.

Reports also say some of the flagged names may belong to citizens, which would reduce the scope of ineligible registrations once counties finish their reviews. That is common when big databases collide. People move, naturalize, or get miskeyed. Mistakes cut both ways: ineligible names can linger, and eligible voters can get tagged in error. The state says removals are underway and an outside review is active, but full vendor and agency records have not been made public in detail.

What This Fight Says About Trust In Government Systems

This episode blends two frustrations that many Americans share. People see a basic duty — keep clean voter lists — tripped up by clumsy software and poor oversight. Then they watch parties argue over access to the very records that could settle the matter. New Jersey’s cleanup shows government can fix errors once found. The RNC’s pressure shows outsiders often need to push to get clear answers. Both realities can be true at the same time.

The near‑term test is narrow and concrete. New Jersey must finish reviewing every flagged record, publish a clear timeline, and explain the specific fix that stops this from happening again. The RNC must ground its claims in documents it can show, not only in rhetoric. Voters deserve simple facts: how many were wrongly added, how many actually voted, how the state removed them, and how the system now blocks repeats. Clean lists, transparent records, and quick corrections are not partisan asks.

Sources:

foxnews.com, politico.com, northjersey.com, cnn.com, republicans-cha.house.gov

© newsalertdaily.org 2026. All rights reserved.